Skip to main content

Origin of the Fortune Cookie: It's NOT Chinese

One of the "must-stops" in SF Chinatown is the Golden Gate Fortune Cookie Factory in Ross Alley. Founded in 1962, the place is about to hit its 60th anniversary later in 2022. 

Golden Gate Fortune Cookie Factory
courtesy author

Feel free to watch them make some in front of you, and get a taste of the unfolded ones, which are miles better than any of those wrapped (censored) you get from (censored). They are often still warm off the circulating multi-griddle. And yes, the fortunes are placed manually. You can also get fancier versions, like dipped, flavored, and so on, or even giant ones. 

But did you ever wonder where it came from? Turns out, it's not Chinese. It's actually Japanese. 

The origins of fortune cookie can be traced back to a Japanese "fortune" (tsujiura) that a temple would offer in a rice cracker (senbei) for a small donation. It is a bit larger than the modern version, darker, and made of sesame and miso. Let's just say, they are fist-sized. The note was simply placed inside the bend, rather than inside the hollow space.  

Japanese tsujiura senbei, fist-sized predecessor
courtesy of Japankuru.com

It is believed that the recipe came with the Japanese immigrants after the Chinese were excluded by the Chinese Exclusionary Act of 1882. One of the most accepted versions was that the recipe was brought to San Francisco as a treat served in the Japanese Tea Garden in the Golden Gate Park, by Makoto Hagiwara, the landscape designer of that place. The story goes that Mr. Hagiwara wanted to produce the Japanese senbei, and would fold them by hand with fortunes to be served to guests of the tea garden in 1914. But when he could not make enough, he entered into a contract with the Benkyodo Candy Factory to mass-produce the senbei. The story goes that Benkyodo's leader, Okamura, advised Hagiwara to change the flavor to have more sugar, vanilla, and butter, to be more acceptable to Westerners, thus the present-day formula for a fortune cookie is born. 

After that, many different Japanese bakeries made the fortune cookie until 1941/1942, when all the Japanese Americans were interned after the Pearl Harbor attack by executive order 9066. Even the Japanese Tea Garden switched to Chinese workers, and the fortune cookies continued. Many businesses left vacant would be bought up by the Chinese. Chinese food enjoyed popularity as they are now the allies and the fortune cookie spread to Chinatown restaurants. As more restaurants started including Westernized "fortunes" with every meal, a new tradition was born. 

Today, Golden Gate Fortune Cookie Company is the only fortune cookie maker left in San Francisco Chinatown and a legacy business where you can witness how they get made every day. 

The fortune cookie is a thoroughly American tradition though. If you take a fortune cookie to China, it will be marketed as an "authentic American fortune cookie". 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

About the author

Kasey is a professional tour guide and amateur historian who specialized in Chinatown History and Tours. You will often find him guiding groups sampling delicious food and learning interesting historical tidbits about Chinatown most weekends.

Popular posts from this blog

Dragon Gate and its Surprising History

You can't come to SF Chinatown and leave out Dragon Gate, aka the Chinatown Gate, at the corner of Bush and Grant. But do you know its history?  Chinatown Gate, aka Dragon Gate, San Francisco Dragon Gate (aka Chinatown Gate, aka Dragon's Gate) was designed by Clayton Lee and others in 1967 in response to a mayoral competition, and his was the winning entry. Originally two gates were proposed, but the other gate leading to Barbary Coast was dropped due to lack of funds, and cost overrun.  The gate itself was designed after a Chinese "pailou 牌樓" or "paifang 牌坊", which were the "gates" that marked separate fang 坊, or "ward" within a city. However, later it evolved into a purely decorative element. As with tradition, the gate faces South, and is composed of a large gate with two smaller side gates.  The gate has a lot of its materials donated by Taiwan (Republic of China) including artisanal tiles, roofing, and the two guardian lions. Despite...
Post a Comment
Read more

Waverly Place: more than just a Chinatown Alley with a Sordid History

Waverly Pl was far more than just an alley in San Francisco. During the earliest days of San Francisco, it was apparently known as "Pike Street", at least until the 1906 Earthquake. I cannot find any historical references on when the name was changed. Many references imply state "Waverly Pl, (formerly Pike St.) while other references imply stated Pike St. Even from the earliest days in Chinatown, it was known as a place of brothels, and allegedly both Bella Cora and Ah Toy, the two most famous madams of Chinatown, have brothels at or very close to Pike St. (later Waverly Pl). For a while, the brothels co-existed with barbers on the same street, where sailors and miners can get a haircut and a shave for 5 cents, and later, 10 cents. So the area was also known as Five Cent Street or Ten Cent Street for a while. But the street remained mired with vices.  A "crime map" prepared for SF City Supervisors in 1885, note the blue and red vices mapped.  courtesy Cornell U...
Post a Comment
Read more

Chop Suey Still Available: New Woey Loy Goey Restaurant

Chop suey is reputed to have been invented in Chinatown. The story goes that in the 1850's, Chinatown is barely established, but word was already out that Chinese food is cheap and delicious. So, late at night, 2 miners fresh off the gold fields, wandered into this Chinese restaurant, even as the owner and cook is about to close up. Already half drunk, they want food, and they want it now! To avoid confrontation, the cook went into the kitchen, found whatever scraps of vegetables left, tossed them all into the wok, whipped up some sauce, added whatever scraps of meat he had, added an egg, and served it on a plate and gave it to the miners.  The miners loved it, to the surprise of the owner, as they wanted the name of the dish as they want to order it again when they come back.  The owner, flabbergasted, simply told them 雜碎 tzap-suey which literally means "mixed scraps". The miners heard that as "chop suey", and a legend was born.  Keep in mind this is a story, a...
Post a Comment
Read more